Understanding Sexual Orientation as a Ground for Seeking Asylum

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has provided numerous interpretive instruments in recent years that recognize the unique security needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex (LGBTI) people. Here, we attempt to understand UNHCR's perspectives on the study of LGBTI claims and the specific problems that which arise as a result of such claims, as well as offer guidance on how to apply these perspectives in assisting asylum seekers.

Thu Jul 07 2022 | Immigration, Appeal and Others | Comments (0)


Emotional,  affectionate, and sexual attraction toward persons of the same or different  genders, or more than one gender, is referred to as sexual orientation. The  LGBTQI group encompasses a diverse range of individuals who have feelings or  desire towards people of the same gender or both genders. It is an individual’s   personal decision and feeling. Many social agents, on the other hand, exert power over  popular opinion as well as a country's rules and laws.

The  Supreme Court of India struck down  Section 377 of the Indian Penal  Code (IPC) in the landmark case of Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India. Prior  to the 2018 judgement, India was one of the countries where homosexual sex  between consenting adults was illegal.
LGBTQI people have long been subjected to various forms of marginalisation,  abuse, and discrimination. Unfortunately, homosexuality and/or homosexual  conduct are still illegal in as many as 75 countries. Thirteen of the 75  nations use the death penalty to punish those who break certain inhumane laws.  When these persecutions are backed up by state legislation, these people have  no choice but to flee their homeland.

Sexual orientation as grounds for asylum

Does LGBTQI  come under the definition of a social  group, political opinion or religion?

Asylum  seekers are also stereotyped as belonging to a specific social community. The  UNHRC considers both the innate, unchangeable, and otherwise intrinsic to  identity features of a social group and the perceived existence of the group  by society when determining its identity. As a result of their fulfillment of  those criteria, homosexuals form a subset within that group.

Principle of  well-founded  fear of being persecuted

When  determining whether or not to grant asylum based on an individual's sexuality,  one of the most important factors to consider is whether or not the person has  "well-founded fear." The word "persecution" does not have a  specified definition in international law or in any convention. It varies  depending on the case's context. However, it is more likely to include abuses  of human rights, posing a threat to democracy or life. Persecution does not  require that the crime or damage be perpetrated by the state. Persecution may  also come from non-state actors, such as the general public.
An individual may already be under a lot of mental strain as a result of their  fear of not being accepted. Furthermore, by seeking refuge, a person does not  want to attract the attention of the state to himself/herself/themselves, and  would rather seek asylum elsewhere. To create a "well-founded fear,"  one does not need to show that he was subjected to forced persecution or that  his/her/their state's authorities were aware of his sexuality. Awareness of  similar cases occurring in the state of origin, as well as the state's  anti-homosexuality stance, serve as legitimate foreseeability.
The asylum procedure

Tips for Asylum Seekers

For  asylum seekers, the most significant source of knowledge can come from the lawyers  or legal experts of the countries to which they wish to apply. There are often legal-aid  cells that provide free assistance. However, finding a great lawyer might not  always be possible due to high fees and generally unfavourable financial  circumstances. This is where non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and social  organisations come in. Well-established NGOs, who have been working on such  issues for a long time, are familiar with the appropriate sources and  prerequisites for successful applications. They may also be able to provide the  moral and emotional support that individuals need during such difficult times,  in addition to the knowledge they can provide. They might be able to assist  people in opening up and telling their stories before they are  interviewed and fact-checked by officials.


Since  there is no clear guideline for granting asylum based on sexual identity,  countries' strategies for shortlisting legitimate applications differ. However,  this approach does not produce the desired result, which is why, despite  numerous applications, few asylums are granted.

Despite  the fact that society's understanding of the LGBTQI community is growing, the  world still has a long way to go. Not everybody can tell the difference between  the colours in this spectrum. Societies must be made aware of these people,  who have long fought for the rights to which they are entitled.

Countries  that have not decriminalised homosexuality or same-sex partnerships may be  subjected to indirect pressure from international meetings, summits, treaties,  and conventions. However, an international law addressing the issues faced by  homosexual asylum seekers is long overdue.

Copyright 2023 – Helpline Law - HLL001


You could get in touch with our team to find a suitable lawyer for assistance.
Helplinelaw has been referring lawyers that fit your needs in terms of seniority and experience since 2001

Other Latest Articles